Update on Fatal Collision – September 25, 2025
On September 24, 2025, at approximately 4:30 P.M., members assigned to NYSP Fredonia investigated the fatal collision on State Route 5 in the town of Portland. The investigation determined that troopers initiated a pursuit after observing Joseph Damico, 44, of Dunkirk, NY, operating a vehicle westbound on State Route 5 in Dunkirk.
The pursuit lasted approximately six minutes and ended when the suspect’s vehicle, a 2010 Jeep Liberty, struck the rear of a 2013 Toyota RAV4. Both vehicles exited the roadway and came to rest in a steep, high-banked drainage ditch. Damico was pronounced deceased at the scene, while the other operator did not sustain any injuries.
The NYSP Collision Reconstruction Unit, Bureau of Criminal Investigation, Forensic Identification Unit, Professional Standards Bureau, and the Attorney General’s Office responded and are involved in the ongoing investigation.
Portland, NY (September 24, 2025) – Troopers from SP Fredonia are investigating a fatal collision that occurred on Wednesday afternoon on State Route 5 in the town of Portland.
The incident happened at approximately 4:30 p.m., prompting the closure of the roadway while emergency crews and law enforcement respond. Detours have been established around the scene.
At this time, details regarding the number of vehicles involved or the identity of the deceased have not been released. Troopers continue to investigate the circumstances surrounding the crash.
Motorists are advised to avoid the area and follow posted detours until the roadway is reopened.
